Check out our social media platforms!
JYE Financial
21st century business media
  • Home
  • Politics

gold manipulation and the meritocracy of technical analysis

5/13/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
by Joshua Enomoto

Noted precious metals investment expert Michael Maloney is no stranger to bold statements and even bolder predictions. Those familiar with Maloney's work will undoubtedly recall his multiple arguments about a deflationary crash in the Dow Jones and an inflationary explosion in the price of bullion. While the case for $10,000 gold and beyond will ultimately be decided by its culmination, or lack thereof, there is another point Maloney made that deserves special consideration.

Back in 2010, Mr. Maloney was invited to speak at the 8th International Banking Forum in Sochi, Russia. There, he gave his usual expose of rampant monetary expansionism by global central banks and an impending sovereign debt and currency crisis. In order to prove some of his heavy accusations, he cited the discipline of technical analysis, specifically mentioning the occurrence of "head-and-shoulders" patterns (part of a sub-sector of technical analysis called Elliot Wave Theory) as a harbinger of bearish events in global equity markets.

Citing technical analysis is nothing new but assigning a nominal probability range for its accuracy is. Technical analysis has always suffered from a "meritocracy" problem by which its calculated implications can only be asserted on a subjective basis. That is, the discipline's usefulness is palpable but sadly unquantifiable. This prevents the technical approach from achieving scientific credibility and will likely never attain such a status.

So it was a bit of a surprise when Maloney in his speech blurted out that technical analysis has a success rate of 55- to 60- percent! There is no doubt that he pulled this number out of his ass (or that he cited someone who pulled this number out of his ass). No entity to my knowledge has ever performed an empirical study on the merits of technical analysis. Further, such a study is made impossible since there is no concrete consensus on what exactly constitutes technical analysis.

However, Maloney should not be blamed for announcing this assertion. While the technical approach lacks scientific standing, that by itself is not reason to dismiss it. Even the widely accepted discipline of accounting lacks such status, and is thus considered an "art." Also, that technical analysis "works" is starting to gain more mainstream acceptance. Media outlets such as CNBC regularly examine select stocks from a fundamental and technical perspective.

But no one has bothered to empirically check the discipline's validity...until now!

Writing a simple program, I calculated the nominal parameters of what constitutes a head-and-shoulders pattern, the key subject of Maloney's discussion on technical analysis. A big part of the reason why no one else had undertaken the task of empirically testing the technical approach is the logistics of the project : no one is going to manually rifle through pages and pages of price charts looking for specific patterns and formations. For such an undertaking, an algorithm is necessary.

Upon completion of my program, I ran it through the entire history of the S&P 500 index, noting when a head-and-shoulders pattern occurred and the percentage by which such a pattern led to a decline in market value. I also ran the exact same experiment for an "inverse" head-and-shoulders pattern, its twin model that implies a bullish future for market valuation.

To my surprise, the head-and-shoulders pattern was remarkably accurate, producing a bearish outcome 67.82% of the time. The inverse variety was even more accurate, producing a bullish probability of 81.3%. This confirmed to me that the U.S. equities market has an upward bias ; indeed, a separate study that I conducted shows that on any given day, the market will produce a positive result more than 52% of the time.

Since we are on the topic of Michael Maloney, I decided to conduct the same experiment with the popular GLD, an exchange-traded fund that tracks the gold market. Here, the head-and-shoulders pattern produced a bearish result 66.82% of the time, a minute 1.49% variance against the S&P 500. But a substantial difference occurred when comparing the inverse pattern, with the GLD only achieved a bullish probability of 79.17%. While this may seem small, the variance of the inverse pattern in the GLD is almost twice that of its equivalent in the S&P index.

On surface level, this tells us that an inverse head-and-shoulders pattern is slightly more likely to "fail" than an equivalent pattern appearing in the equities market. Such an observation may embolden the gold and silver bugs who adamantly claim that the bullion market is rigged. From a non-partial perspective, it is interesting and worthy of further research. The variance between the inverse results of the two markets is in my opinion statistically significant ; however, on a pure nominal basis, it will be difficult to condemn an entire market as being manipulated because of a 2% discrepancy in a discipline that can often produce more questions than answers.

Even my own analysis is subject to criticism. Even though the methodologies that I have applied were consistent throughout the analysis, some of the "hits" that my algorithm found would not be considered a true head-and-shoulders pattern. This meets an input dilemma (as the programmer, I had to define to the computer what a head-and-shoulders pattern is) and an empirical dilemma (nobody knows what a head-and-shoulders pattern really is). Using statistical language, my degree of error is unknown. Ironically, an attempt to quantify the degree of error will lead to an existential discussion and an inordinate amount of academic bickering, a journey that I just plainly refuse to undertake.    

Still, the consistency of methodology over several years of data does confirm semi-empirically what technicians have always believed : technical analysis is accurate. And when performed by the right people, it may be more accurate than you may be giving it credit for! 


0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Stock blog

    Direct.Pointed.Insight. Financial analysis without the filler.

    Archives

    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014

    Author

    All blogs written by Joshua Enomoto unless otherwise noted

    Categories

    All
    Accounting
    Adam Silver
    Adp
    Advisor
    Alex-jones
    America
    Analysis
    Anecdote
    Annuity
    Art Of War
    Ask
    Assessment
    Assets
    Bank
    Bankers
    Banking
    Basketball
    BBY
    Ben Bernanke
    Bid
    Black Swan
    Bonds
    Books
    Brendan Eich
    Budget
    California Chrome
    Capita
    Capital
    Capitalism
    Cash
    CBO
    Central Bank
    Ceo
    Certificate
    Chairman
    Chairwoman
    Charts
    China
    Clippers
    Cnbc
    Commodities
    Commodity
    Common Stock
    Communism
    Company
    Conglomerate
    Congressional Budget Office
    Conspiracy
    Conspiracy Theories
    Consultant
    Consultation
    Consumer
    Consumer-confidence
    Contrarian
    Contrary
    Corporate
    Corporate-america
    Cost
    Cost Cutting
    Crash
    Currency Evaluation
    Curve
    Defensive
    Defensive Strategies
    Deflation
    Democrat
    Department Of Labor
    Depression
    Derivatives
    Disparity
    Divergence
    Dividend
    Dividends
    DMA
    Donald Sterling
    Dow 30
    Dow Jones
    Earners
    Earnings
    Eastern Bloc
    Economic
    Economics
    Economy
    Effective
    Employ
    Employee
    Employment
    Enomoto
    Equality
    Equities
    ETF
    EU
    European Union
    Executive
    Fat Tail
    Fed
    Federal Reserve
    Fill Or Kill
    Finance
    Firing
    Fiscal
    Football
    Forecast
    Forecasting
    Forward Guidance
    Fund
    Fundamental
    Fundamental Analysis
    Gay Rights
    Gdp
    Gold
    Goldsilver
    Good For The Day
    Gov
    Government
    Government Shutdown
    Govt
    Go With The Money
    Graphs
    Gross Domestic Product
    Growth
    Hard Assets
    Head And Shoulders
    High Frequency Trading
    Holodomor
    Human Resources
    Implied
    Income
    Independence Square
    Index
    Indices
    Inflation
    Insider Trading
    Institution
    Insurance
    Interest
    Investment
    Iron Curtain
    Janet Yellen
    January Effect
    Japan
    Japanese Candlestick
    Jcp
    J.c. Penney
    Jobs
    Jobs Report
    Joshua Enomoto
    Kiev
    Kyiv
    Labor
    Labor Department
    LA Clippers
    Layoffs
    Leadership
    Ledger
    Liabilities
    Los Angeles
    Madden
    Maidan Nezalezhnosti
    Main Street
    Management
    Margin
    Markets
    Media
    Metals
    Metals-complex
    Michael-lewis
    Michael-maloney
    Middle-class
    Minimum Wage
    Monetary Policy
    Money
    Money Story
    Monopoly
    Moving Average
    Mozilla
    Nasdaq
    National Debt
    NBA
    Net
    Net Profitability
    New York Stock Exchange
    NFL
    Nikkei 225
    NYSE
    Obama
    Obligation
    OkCupid
    Options
    Orange Revolution
    Order
    Paul Craig Roberts
    Policy
    Politics
    Portfolio
    Precious-metals
    Probability
    Prop 8
    Proposition 8
    Protests
    Public
    Punt
    Punting
    QE3
    Quantitative Easing
    Rate Change
    Rates
    Recovery
    Register
    Regression
    Republican
    Residual
    Retail
    Retail Market
    Retirement
    Revenue
    Risk
    Risk Management
    Russia
    Russian
    Sales
    Sanctions
    Savings
    Scalp
    Scandal
    Securities
    Share
    Silver
    Simulation
    Soviet
    Soviet Union
    S&p
    S&P 500
    Spread
    Statistics
    Sterling
    Steve Coburn
    Stock Market
    Stock Market Trends
    Stocks
    Stop-loss
    Sun Tzu
    Superbowl
    Taper
    Tapering
    Target
    Tax
    Technical Analysis
    Termination
    Tokyo Stock Exchange
    Trade
    Treasuries
    Trigger
    Ukraine
    Ukrainian
    Unions
    United States
    Uprising
    U.s.
    Usa
    U.S. Labor Department
    Variable
    Violence
    Wage
    Wall Street
    Washington
    Wealth
    Work
    Workers
    Yield
    Yields

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.